Skip to main

Best Diner in Commack

Taste the Best in Every Bite!

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Prime Burger

Add Item

California Turkey Burger

Turkey burger topped with avocado and crispy fried onions

Add Item

Breakfast Cheeseburger

Beef burger topped with cheese, fried egg and bacon

Add Item

Greek Turkey Burger

Topped with sautéed spinach and feta

Add Item

Fried Mac Burger

Fried mac & cheese crescents with American cheese & bacon

Add Item

Hot Rueben Sandwich

Corned beef on grilled rye bread with melted Swiss cheese and sauerkraut

Add Item

20 oz. Skirt Steak

Add Item

Chicken Fingers Deluxe

Served with French fries and onion rings

Add Item

Fried Filet Deluxe

Served with French fries, onion rings and tartar sauce

Add Item

Classic Avocado Toast

Avocado, tomatoes, red onions, balsamic, mesclun on multigrain toast topped with goat cheese

Add Item

Welcome to Candlelight Diner

Welcome to Candlelight Diner
Located on Veterans Memorial Highway, Candlelight Diner has been a cherished family-owned staple in Commack for generations. Since 1969, we’ve proudly served scratch-made meals crafted with care, from our locally famous pasta salad and hand-formed burgers to homemade pancakes and desserts baked fresh daily by our in-house baker. Rooted in tradition and built on warm hospitality, Candlelight isn’t just a place to eat, it’s a place to come home to. Where every meal is made to feel like a memory.

Simple, Fresh, and Delicious Meals

Simple, Fresh, and Delicious Meals
At Candlelight Diner, we take pride in serving timeless, satisfying meals made from scratch with the freshest ingredients. Our locally loved pasta salad has become a customer favorite, crafted with care and consistency. For something heartier, don’t miss the French Onion Burger or our signature Pancakes Ala Candlelight — each one a comforting classic. Whether you’re stopping in for lunch or sitting down to dinner, every dish is made to hit the spot and feel like home.
Easy Meals for Busy Days

Easy Meals for Busy Days

Life can be busy, but that doesn’t mean you should settle for anything less than great food. At Candlelight Diner, we make ordering easy. You can dine in for a relaxed meal, pick up your order, or have it delivered straight to your door. Simply place your order online, and we'll handle the rest. No long waits just delicious food, hot and fresh, delivered right to you. Whether feeding the family or enjoying a meal alone, we make it simple to enjoy the best meals.
Order Now

A Bite of Comfort in Every Meal

Sep into Candlelight Diner and explore the mouthwatering dishes waiting for you. From our Almost Famous Greek Salad and indulgent Mac & Cheese with Crispy Chicken Cutlet to our signature Pancakes Ala Candlelight and the hearty French Onion Burger, every photo captures the hearty meals we’re proud to serve. Whether you're craving something light or filling, we’ve got the perfect dish ready for you!

Catering for Every Celebration

Catering for Every Celebration
Planning a party or special event?
Let Candlelight Diner make it unforgettable with our custom catering services. Whether it’s a family gathering, corporate celebration, or any occasion worth savoring, we’ll bring our homemade flavors straight to you. From crowd-pleasing favorites to signature dishes, we’ll handle the food — so you can focus on making memories.
inquire Now

We’re Here When You Need Us

We’re Here When You Need Us
Candlelight Diner is always here for you.
Join us at 56 Veterans Memorial Hwy in Commack, NY, and enjoy a meal made from scratch and served with heart. Whether you’re dining in, picking up, or ordering online, we’re ready to deliver the great food and friendly service you’ve come to expect. At Candlelight Diner, we’re always in the kitchen — cooking up comfort when you need it most.

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Stopped in for take out for 2. I placed my order at the counter with a warm and helpful waitress. Asked how long (15min) & ran across the parking lot while it was being cooked. Back within 15 and my meals were out on time. The lovely hostess reminded me to check my order prior to leaving. I'm sure the hunger helped, but my pastrami Reuben was delicious. Unfortunately the fries had cooled by the time I arrived at my destination, but they weren't bad, maybe they needed pepper or salt to taste. Meal came with sauerkraut and a pickle. Other customers in the diner all seemed to be enjoying themselves. I would definitely come back here.

Sarah F

Sarah F

One of the best Diners on the Island! I seem to gravitate towards the delicious egg omelets and blueberry pancakes.

J C.

J C.

If, for whatever unfortunate reason, you find yourself in Commack and need a place to eat, I can't recommend this place enough. The food is good, the service is fantastic, and everyone there is really nice. My dad and I both frequent this diner and we haven't had a bad experience with it yet.

Justin W

Justin W

The candlelight Diner has been around forever And that's because of the great service and excellent food. This is a family run business. Our waitress, Victoria was very attentive funny and polite. My family and I always enjoy going to the diner whether it be for breakfast or dinner. Very consistent. I would highly recommend this restaurant / diner .

Jean

Jean

Really enjoyed this diner! The food was fresh and full of flavor, and the portions were perfect. Super clean inside and the staff was so friendly and welcoming. It’s the kind of place you’ll want to come back to!

Alexandra L

Alexandra L

My wife and I enjoy trying different diners. So far this is our favorite! The place is clean, good service and great food.

Victor D.

Victor D.

We'd love to hear about your experience with us!

Did you enjoy your recent meal at Candlelight Diner? We'd love to hear about it! Your positive Google reviews not only help fellow food enthusiasts discover our delicious food, cozy atmosphere, unique menu, and friendly staff. But also support our local business. Please take a few moments to rate our restaurant on Google and share your experience.
Candlelight Google Profile

Dine In

Catering

Delivery

Dine In

Take Out

Private Dining Room

Vegetarian Dishes

Watching Sports Available

Gluten Free Options

Candlelight Diner Online Rewards

Candlelight Diner Online Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Candlelight News Letter!

Join our News Letter to receive the latest promotions and discounts we have for you!

Frequently asked questions

We are known for French Fries, Meatloaf, Grilled Cheese, Carrot Cake, Pasta, Quesadillas, Grilled Cheese Sandwich, Pudding, Caesar Salad, Pizza, Sandwiches, Mozzarella Sticks, Gyro, Calamari, Pulled Pork, Mac and Cheese, Brunch, Cold Brew, Fried Chicken, Apple Pie, Roast Beef Sandwich, Cheese Steak, Lemon Meringue Pie, Greek Food, Arugula Salad, Italian Food, Wings, Chicken Salad, BBQ, Napoleon, American Food, Philly Cheese Steak, Dessert, Avocado Toast, Ravioli, Omelette, Soup, Coffee, Pasta Salad, Buffalo Wings, Bagels, Espresso, Chicken and Waffles, Deli Sandwiches, Smoothie, Eggs, Souvlaki, Sausage, Chili, Milkshake, Waldorf Salad, Tuna Melt, Home Fries, Taco Salad, Vegetarian Food, Cheeseburger, Pastrami Sandwich, Turkey Burger, Salads, Cobb Salad, Waffles, Pie, Grilled Cheese Sandwiches, Chef Salad, Fries, Pulled Pork Sandwich, Breakfast, Toasted Bagel, French Dip, Grilled Chicken, Baklava, Tuna Salad Sandwich, Cheesecake, Bananas Foster, and Burgers

We serve Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner

Yes, we offer Delivery and Takeout

We are located in Commack, NY at 56 Veterans Memorial Hwy

Our location